I enjoy knitting.
Very helpful employee the one time I was there.
It's a new store, so I am positive that the selection will grow and the atmosphere will improve.
As for things we like in a yarn store --- the options to pick from on the top left hand side of the page --- I think you should add something about the friendliness and/or helpfulness of the workers and/or owners. That, for me is THE biggest consideration of whether I would go back. And in NY, there are quite a few of those.
Thanks for this great site!